Title | Posted |
---|---|
The origin of the Manticoran technical edge | Nov 2004 |
Is the destroyer obsolete as a ship type? | Nov 2004 |
Arsenal ships based upon ammunition colliers | Nov 2004 |
Off-bore missile targeting | Nov 2004 |
Single-drive fusion-powered missiles | Nov 2004 |
Order of Battle: The Siege of Earth | Nov 2004 |
Order of Battle: First Clash - The Vanguard | Nov 2004 |
Order of Battle: The Battle of Zeta Trianguli Australis | Nov 2004 |
Order of Battle: Second Clash - The Main Body | Nov 2004 |
Effective intercept range for counter-missiles | Dec 2004 |
A collection of posts by David Weber containing background information for his stories, collected and generously made available Joe Buckley.
A suggestion has been made that it would make sense to put drives into shipkiller missiles of sufficient power to make them immune to wedge kill by a counter-missile. Is this practical? Could it be done as the final stage of a MDM?
No, it isn't. And it won't be -- ever. I believe we've had this discussion before. You cannot -- not "it would be hard," not "only possible with great difficulty," but cannot -- build a missile drive sufficiently powerful to take out another missile (or counter-missile) drive without being taken out itself. End of story. The physical size constraints make it impossible. That's why counter-missiles have used their impeller wedges as their primary missile-killing weapon for so long.