Archives

Title Posted
Keyhole platform survivability Nov 2006
Coursers and the Fall of Kontovar Oct 2006
The nature of the hradani and the Rage Oct 2006
Survival of the Church of Humanity Unchained Sep 2006
Relationships between universes Sep 2006
Misconceptions about the League Aug 2006
Stability of the Republic of Haven and system secession Jul 2006
FTL fire control communication lag May 2006
Expanding upon the Eridani Edict Dec 2005
Manticore's relationship with Beowulf Dec 2005

Filters

Narrow the posts above by selecting a series or specifying a keyword.

Options

Pearls of Weber

A collection of posts by David Weber containing background information for his stories, collected and generously made available Joe Buckley.

Arsenal ships based upon ammunition colliers

  • Series: Honorverse
  • Date: November 14, 2004

Would it make sense to equip ammunition ships, which already have huge numbers of pods on board, with the fire control to effectively deploy those pods?


Yes and no. In a desperate situation, when the alternatives are a successful self-defense or destruction, with no other option possible, it would make a lot of sense. In terms of providing ammunition ships with a capability which might tempt them into straying into the reach of enemy weapons, it would be a terrible idea. So far, the Manticoran Admiralty has preferred for ammunition ships to know perfectly well that they have no business at all in range of any enemy weapon system. Their ammunition ships have decent (at least for merchant hulls) sidewalls, counter-missile tubes, point defense, and EW, but those are designed solely to defend the ship while she runs away as rapidly as possible. The expense to mount fire control to let it make effective use of its pods defensively or offensively, plus providing the additional trained manpower to make effective use of the weapons in question, would not be trivial. Taken altogether, it is unlikely that the Manties, at least, are going to be doing this sort of thing. In their estimation, an ammunition ship is worth considerably more than a single SD(P), and they are going to do everything they can to keep the said ammunition ships out of the line of fire from the get-go.