runsforcelery wrote:Randomiser wrote:So, are the Prohibitions all gathered together somewhere or are they scattered through the dozens of books of instructions? I'm thinking of how difficult it is to be an Intendant and make comprehensive rulings on what is or isn't OK.
There are actually two "sets" of Proscriptions.
The really important, central Proscription --- the limitation to wind, water, or muscle power --- is in the central
Writ in multiple places. "This is the first and great Prohibition; upon it stand all the laws and commands."
There are also secondary Proscriptions, which are equally authoritative but govern other aspects of life, and those are stated within the "books" (of however many volumes) of the Archangels into whose spheres the behavior in question would fall. Those proscriptions (like Pasquale's absolute ban on certain types of asbestos or phosphorous) are contained in the text where their subjects are discussed and also in a master index volume for each multi-volume book. And the indexes of Proscriptions for all the
Writ's books are then compiled in the master index volumes which serve the intendants as their primary reference work when ruling on a process or a potential innovation. In particularly thorny rulings, it may be necessary to go back to the original text and read the exact context of the Proscription rather than relying upon the summaries in the indexes proper, but the appropriate chapter and verse is always listed in the index entry.
Being an
honest intendant was never a walk in the park, but it wasn't exactly impossible, either.
IIRC, there was an infodump in one of the books about this. The lesser proscriptions aren't referred to as "Proscriptions", but are called "anathemas" or something because this or that Archangel disliked something, and the results of doing some anathema (like the abestos and phosphorous) were explained as curses from whichever Archangel supposedly took offense.
This became important in Charis' chemistry research where a pre-Inner Circle Sandra Lewis used the anathemas list as a guide to find substances she could make explode on demand. And of course everyone quietly ignores (or secretly rejoices in) the fact that using "Angelic curses" as weapons and tools subverts the very intent of the whole anathema system to begin with. But they keep doing it anyway because if the Angels really didn't approve, they wouldn't keep supplying "curses" on demand.