Topic Actions

Topic Search

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 28 guests

Safehold Oil and Gas Industry

This fascinating series is a combination of historical seafaring, swashbuckling adventure, and high technological science-fiction. Join us in a discussion!
Re: Safehold Oil and Gas Industry
Post by n7axw   » Tue Jan 26, 2016 2:51 am

n7axw
Fleet Admiral

Posts: 5997
Joined: Wed Jan 22, 2014 8:54 pm
Location: Viborg, SD

Laenole wrote:I had forgotten the reference to South Charis and Emerald Island having extensive oilfields. It is in MTaT Chapter VII, April Year of God 896. Thanks, Don.

But the paragraph it is in seems to imply that kerosene is not being made presently. It says that Zhansyn Wyllys, the distillation enthusiast from the dragon oil family, could develop extracting kerosene from coal tar. It goes on to say that this plus Safehold’s current drilling and pumping tech along with the oilfields “was likely to lead to a completely new industry”. This seems to indicate to me that the oilfields are known only in Shan-wei’s database in Owl’s library.

While development of the petroleum industry is in Safehold’s long term interest, it is a tough call as to whether distillation should be applied to the production of Poudre B or Cordite. The original Poudre B formula was 68.2% insoluble guncotton, 29.8% soluble nitrocellulose gelatinized with ether, and 2% paraffin. It was almost immediately replaced by a more stable version that added amyl alcohol as a stabilizer. Later, the amyl alcohol was replaces by aniline.

The current Cordite is a triple-base explosive (contains 3 explosive chemicals) that needs a raw material produced through the use of an electric arc furnace. The earliest version is a double-base mixture of 58% nitroglycerin, 37% guncotton, and 5% petroleum jelly. Acetone is then used as a solvent to produced cords of the product (hence its name) of the desired size.

Currently, Charis is producing guncotton and nitroglycerin. The ether can be produced by the reaction of ethanol and sulfuric acid. The amyl alcohol stabilizer for Poudre B can be obtained from the high boiling residue of the ethanol distillation. Acetone can be obtained by the reaction of eggshells or limestone (Calcium carbonate) with vinegar.

The petroleum jelly is obtained by the vacuum distillation of the waxy deposits from drilling or refining. The best stabilizer for Poudre B, aniline, can be obtained by distilling coal tar for its benzene, reacting it with nitric acid, then reducing it with an inorganic sulfide.

Since all components of Poudre B, including the first stabilizer, amyl alcohol, are available now, it is a good initial target. The cordite would have to wait for the actual development of the petroleum industry. Since coal tar seems to be the initial target of distillation projects, obtaining benzene to make the better aniline stabilizer for Poudre B seems a logical part of the project. This would also stimulate the future development of the chemical industry by the eventual production of aniline dyes.

Longer term, the kerosene from coal tar and eventually coal would develop a market for a major component of crude oil. Of course, the gasoline, diesel, and bunker oil will be valuable for different internal combustion machines. It seems to me that producing Poudre B will be quicker and more likely to be used in this war.


Probably not in this war. Given the lead time that any of this would need to take hold and bear fruit, we are still looking intermediate to long term future. The war will probably wind down next summer if ATSoT is to be the last in the current story arc.

Don

-
When any group seeks political power in God's name, both religion and politics are instantly corrupted.
Top
Re: Safehold Oil and Gas Industry
Post by lyonheart   » Tue Jan 26, 2016 5:23 am

lyonheart
Fleet Admiral

Posts: 4853
Joined: Tue Sep 08, 2009 11:27 pm

Hi Laenole,

Welcome to the forums, please enjoy your favorite simulated beverage on the simulated forum. ;)

We had various references to oil, rock oil and gas from OAR onward as the 'Earl of Black Water' indicated, with further mention of other fields etc in other books; so while exploitation isn't apparently yet up to the ancient Chinese, medicinal, glues and binders, local road construction, and water proofing besides obvious fuel use were probably in play before Merlin.

The advantages of gas and oil for heating in Howsmyn's various industries seem the most likely current route to more general use, eventually from CoGA spies to its remnants.

Given the early American oil drilling industry was driven by the cost of kerosene, and Merlin's concern about the rate of the various -whale species already being consumed for their lantern type oil etc, Charis may have been at the pre-1859 stage America was, with large fleets eager to meet the popular demand.

L


Laenole wrote:I had forgotten the reference to South Charis and Emerald Island having extensive oilfields. It is in MTaT Chapter VII, April Year of God 896. Thanks, Don.

But the paragraph it is in seems to imply that kerosene is not being made presently. It says that Zhansyn Wyllys, the distillation enthusiast from the dragon oil family, could develop extracting kerosene from coal tar. It goes on to say that this plus Safehold’s current drilling and pumping tech along with the oilfields “was likely to lead to a completely new industry”. This seems to indicate to me that the oilfields are known only in Shan-wei’s database in Owl’s library.

While development of the petroleum industry is in Safehold’s long term interest, it is a tough call as to whether distillation should be applied to the production of Poudre B or Cordite. The original Poudre B formula was 68.2% insoluble guncotton, 29.8% soluble nitrocellulose gelatinized with ether, and 2% paraffin. It was almost immediately replaced by a more stable version that added amyl alcohol as a stabilizer. Later, the amyl alcohol was replaces by aniline.

The current Cordite is a triple-base explosive (contains 3 explosive chemicals) that needs a raw material produced through the use of an electric arc furnace. The earliest version is a double-base mixture of 58% nitroglycerin, 37% guncotton, and 5% petroleum jelly. Acetone is then used as a solvent to produced cords of the product (hence its name) of the desired size.

Currently, Charis is producing guncotton and nitroglycerin. The ether can be produced by the reaction of ethanol and sulfuric acid. The amyl alcohol stabilizer for Poudre B can be obtained from the high boiling residue of the ethanol distillation. Acetone can be obtained by the reaction of eggshells or limestone (Calcium carbonate) with vinegar.

The petroleum jelly is obtained by the vacuum distillation of the waxy deposits from drilling or refining. The best stabilizer for Poudre B, aniline, can be obtained by distilling coal tar for its benzene, reacting it with nitric acid, then reducing it with an inorganic sulfide.

Since all components of Poudre B, including the first stabilizer, amyl alcohol, are available now, it is a good initial target. The cordite would have to wait for the actual development of the petroleum industry. Since coal tar seems to be the initial target of distillation projects, obtaining benzene to make the better aniline stabilizer for Poudre B seems a logical part of the project. This would also stimulate the future development of the chemical industry by the eventual production of aniline dyes.

Longer term, the kerosene from coal tar and eventually coal would develop a market for a major component of crude oil. Of course, the gasoline, diesel, and bunker oil will be valuable for different internal combustion machines. It seems to me that producing Poudre B will be quicker and more likely to be used in this war.
Any snippet or post from RFC is good if not great!
Top
Re: Safehold Oil and Gas Industry
Post by Louis R   » Fri Feb 05, 2016 2:29 pm

Louis R
Rear Admiral

Posts: 1298
Joined: Thu Jan 01, 2015 9:25 pm

Unfounded assumption time:

Historically, the term Black or Dark Water has _not_ referred to petroleum far more often than it has. One of the better known examples, as an illustration, is the dubh ghlas of lowland Scotland, so named in the mists of antiquity for the color of the water [it later gave its name to the family and Earldom of Douglas - "Earl of Black Water" is a literal translation of Earl of Douglas]. But that color comes from the peat it runs through, like many of the other Black or Blackwater Rivers I know [there are a couple in northern Ontario, too]. Some, like the Niger, carry heavy loads of black silt. Quite a few were simply named after somebody from the Black family.

What none of the ones I've tracked down have is an association with petroleum. Or even coal, for that matter. So it's just as likely that the Earl of Black Water is presiding over a deep murky pond as a tar pit.


lyonheart wrote:Hi Laenole,

Welcome to the forums, please enjoy your favorite simulated beverage on the simulated forum. ;)

We had various references to oil, rock oil and gas from OAR onward as the 'Earl of Black Water' indicated, with further mention of other fields etc in other books; so while exploitation isn't apparently yet up to the ancient Chinese, medicinal, glues and binders, local road construction, and water proofing besides obvious fuel use were probably in play before Merlin.

< snip >

Top
Re: Safehold Oil and Gas Industry
Post by saber964   » Fri Feb 05, 2016 5:58 pm

saber964
Admiral

Posts: 2423
Joined: Thu Dec 13, 2012 8:41 pm
Location: Spokane WA USA

Louis R wrote:Unfounded assumption time:

Historically, the term Black or Dark Water has _not_ referred to petroleum far more often than it has. One of the better known examples, as an illustration, is the dubh ghlas of lowland Scotland, so named in the mists of antiquity for the color of the water [it later gave its name to the family and Earldom of Douglas - "Earl of Black Water" is a literal translation of Earl of Douglas]. But that color comes from the peat it runs through, like many of the other Black or Blackwater Rivers I know [there are a couple in northern Ontario, too]. Some, like the Niger, carry heavy loads of black silt. Quite a few were simply named after somebody from the Black family.

What none of the ones I've tracked down have is an association with petroleum. Or even coal, for that matter. So it's just as likely that the Earl of Black Water is presiding over a deep murky pond as a tar pit.


lyonheart wrote:Hi Laenole,

Welcome to the forums, please enjoy your favorite simulated beverage on the simulated forum. ;)

We had various references to oil, rock oil and gas from OAR onward as the 'Earl of Black Water' indicated, with further mention of other fields etc in other books; so while exploitation isn't apparently yet up to the ancient Chinese, medicinal, glues and binders, local road construction, and water proofing besides obvious fuel use were probably in play before Merlin.

< snip >




Very true, try the Rios Nigroes and Solomon in Brazil. They are so named because of the color of the water from silt. The Nigroes is black in color and the Solomon is pale yellow in color
Top
Re: Safehold Oil and Gas Industry
Post by WeberFan   » Fri Feb 05, 2016 10:31 pm

WeberFan
Captain (Junior Grade)

Posts: 374
Joined: Fri Mar 27, 2015 10:12 am

SNIP...
lyonheart wrote:The advantages of gas and oil for heating in Howsmyn's various industries seem the most likely current route to more general use, eventually from CoGA spies to its remnants.


I don't recall the relative heat content of coal versus heavy fuel oil, but IMHO the main (by far) benefit of oil versus coal for furnaces is the ease of transportation. Coal transport requires a continuous infrastructure. Oil transport requires one-time infrastructure building (the pipeline).

Then once it's in place, the oilfields supply local (to the manufacturing facility) "service tanks" that (in turn) supply fuel oil to the furnaces. The burner heads in the furnaces don't even have to be precision-designed - just "good enough." But the more precise they are - the more you can atomize the fuel and the better you can A) mix it with the combustion air and B) control the oil-air mix, the better heating you'll get.

With just a little care and experimentation, I could reasonably see Charis factories generating and using high-pressure, superheated steam to drive steam turbines as well as reciprocating steam engines. This would give them immense flexibility and would increase manufacturing capability by an order of magnitude - if not even more.
Top
Re: Safehold Oil and Gas Industry
Post by WeberFan   » Fri Feb 05, 2016 10:37 pm

WeberFan
Captain (Junior Grade)

Posts: 374
Joined: Fri Mar 27, 2015 10:12 am

Louis R wrote:Unfounded assumption time:

Historically, the term Black or Dark Water has _not_ referred to petroleum far more often than it has. One of the better known examples, as an illustration, is the dubh ghlas of lowland Scotland, so named in the mists of antiquity for the color of the water [it later gave its name to the family and Earldom of Douglas - "Earl of Black Water" is a literal translation of Earl of Douglas]. But that color comes from the peat it runs through, like many of the other Black or Blackwater Rivers I know [there are a couple in northern Ontario, too]. Some, like the Niger, carry heavy loads of black silt. Quite a few were simply named after somebody from the Black family.

What none of the ones I've tracked down have is an association with petroleum. Or even coal, for that matter. So it's just as likely that the Earl of Black Water is presiding over a deep murky pond as a tar pit.


lyonheart wrote:Hi Laenole,

Welcome to the forums, please enjoy your favorite simulated beverage on the simulated forum. ;)

We had various references to oil, rock oil and gas from OAR onward as the 'Earl of Black Water' indicated, with further mention of other fields etc in other books; so while exploitation isn't apparently yet up to the ancient Chinese, medicinal, glues and binders, local road construction, and water proofing besides obvious fuel use were probably in play before Merlin.

< snip >


You're absolutely right Louis. Water color being black means next to nothing when it comes to being a predictor of hydrocarbons being present. Silt being present is one way to get "black water" as you say. Another is the presence of lots of organic matter (peat immediately comes to mind). A better predictor is the telltale "sheen" that you see when you have oil floating on water. Take a sample bucket full of water and let it sit quietly for a few minutes. The oil will invariably rise to the top. Shine a light on it and look for the sheen... Of course that tells you only that hydrocarbons are present... Tells you NOTHING about how MUCH is there. :roll:
Top
Re: Safehold Oil and Gas Industry
Post by lyonheart   » Sat Feb 06, 2016 1:20 am

lyonheart
Fleet Admiral

Posts: 4853
Joined: Tue Sep 08, 2009 11:27 pm

Hi Weber-Fan, Louis R;

Yup, all very true guys; so thanks and more kudos for your brevity.

OTOH, we know there are evidently lots of oil fields; NTM from previous thread discussions what some consider to be offshore oil fields [the green patches], known to Shan Wei, not just the shoals in red-brown etc as RFC posted from the maps in BSRA and MTaT, but at the moment we can only wait for textev confirmation [probably after the 20 year hiatus] because he was being so coy about it IIRC, NTM since its been so many years.

Thus I won't be too surprised if 'Black Water' and some other corroborating references do indeed mean oil fields.

L


WeberFan wrote:
Louis R wrote:Unfounded assumption time:

Historically, the term Black or Dark Water has _not_ referred to petroleum far more often than it has. One of the better known examples, as an illustration, is the dubh ghlas of lowland Scotland, so named in the mists of antiquity for the color of the water [it later gave its name to the family and Earldom of Douglas - "Earl of Black Water" is a literal translation of Earl of Douglas]. But that color comes from the peat it runs through, like many of the other Black or Blackwater Rivers I know [there are a couple in northern Ontario, too]. Some, like the Niger, carry heavy loads of black silt. Quite a few were simply named after somebody from the Black family.

What none of the ones I've tracked down have is an association with petroleum. Or even coal, for that matter. So it's just as likely that the Earl of Black Water is presiding over a deep murky pond as a tar pit.


*quote="lyonheart"*Hi Laenole,

Welcome to the forums, please enjoy your favorite simulated beverage on the simulated forum. ;)

We had various references to oil, rock oil and gas from OAR onward as the 'Earl of Black Water' indicated, with further mention of other fields etc in other books; so while exploitation isn't apparently yet up to the ancient Chinese, medicinal, glues and binders, local road construction, and water proofing besides obvious fuel use were probably in play before Merlin.

< snip >

*quote*

You're absolutely right Louis. Water color being black means next to nothing when it comes to being a predictor of hydrocarbons being present. Silt being present is one way to get "black water" as you say. Another is the presence of lots of organic matter (peat immediately comes to mind). A better predictor is the telltale "sheen" that you see when you have oil floating on water. Take a sample bucket full of water and let it sit quietly for a few minutes. The oil will invariably rise to the top. Shine a light on it and look for the sheen... Of course that tells you only that hydrocarbons are present... Tells you NOTHING about how MUCH is there. :roll:
Any snippet or post from RFC is good if not great!
Top
Re: Safehold Oil and Gas Industry
Post by WeberFan   » Sat Feb 06, 2016 9:22 am

WeberFan
Captain (Junior Grade)

Posts: 374
Joined: Fri Mar 27, 2015 10:12 am

Thanks, Lyonhart.

I wouldn't be surprised either. You take organic material. Bury it. Subject it to pressure and time. Voila. Hydrocarbons. Coal initially. Then over time (lots, and lots of time) the hydrocarbon molecules begin breaking down and the molecules get shorter and shorter. You get (first) asphalt... Then oil... Then gas...

All the descriptions of Safehold suggest that (even before Shan Wei's terraforming) it was very "Earthlike." This means that all the hydrocarbon-making processes that took place on Earth over billions of years would also take place on Safehold.

Haven't seen textev for it, but if I were a betting man I'd say there are LOTS of hydrocarbons available. All over the place! :D

Now I guess we just have to see if MWW explores that path. I confess I'm a bit anxious, a bit excited, and a bit curious about how he might do it.
Top
Re: Safehold Oil and Gas Industry
Post by AirTech   » Sun Feb 07, 2016 7:46 pm

AirTech
Captain of the List

Posts: 476
Joined: Mon Dec 09, 2013 4:37 am
Location: Deeeep South (Australia) (most of the time...)

WeberFan wrote:SNIP...
lyonheart wrote:The advantages of gas and oil for heating in Howsmyn's various industries seem the most likely current route to more general use, eventually from CoGA spies to its remnants.


I don't recall the relative heat content of coal versus heavy fuel oil, but IMHO the main (by far) benefit of oil versus coal for furnaces is the ease of transportation. Coal transport requires a continuous infrastructure. Oil transport requires one-time infrastructure building (the pipeline).

Then once it's in place, the oilfields supply local (to the manufacturing facility) "service tanks" that (in turn) supply fuel oil to the furnaces. The burner heads in the furnaces don't even have to be precision-designed - just "good enough." But the more precise they are - the more you can atomize the fuel and the better you can A) mix it with the combustion air and B) control the oil-air mix, the better heating you'll get.

With just a little care and experimentation, I could reasonably see Charis factories generating and using high-pressure, superheated steam to drive steam turbines as well as reciprocating steam engines. This would give them immense flexibility and would increase manufacturing capability by an order of magnitude - if not even more.


Coal can be pumped too (when mixed as a slurry with water) or blown down pipes.
Historically however there was a preference for lump coal for boiler and blast furnace firing (as the air paths are maintained). Coal dust firing was tried (and is still used in most coal fired thermal power stations)but was found to be harder to control in the small scales used in mobile steam engines (I am aware of one locomotive (R707) in Australia that used it but it had issues with poor traction - it couldn't absorb the power it generated and a tendency toward tender fires and explosions if the nitrogen blanket was not maintained (Diesel fuel was cheaper too)). http://www.707operations.com.au/Main.asp?_=R%20Class%20History
The US Army M1 Abrams is certified to use coal dust firing on it power turbine in an emergency (at the expense of much shorter overhaul intervals - due to clinker in the power turbine).
So you can build a coal fired industry - oil is just a bit easier.
Top
Re: Safehold Oil and Gas Industry
Post by Weird Harold   » Sun Feb 07, 2016 9:56 pm

Weird Harold
Fleet Admiral

Posts: 4478
Joined: Thu Apr 24, 2014 10:25 pm
Location: "Lost Wages", NV

AirTech wrote:Coal can be pumped too (when mixed as a slurry with water) or blown down pipes.
Historically however there was a preference for lump coal for boiler and blast furnace firing (as the air paths are maintained). Coal dust firing was tried (and is still used in most coal fired thermal power stations)but was found to be harder to control in the small scales used in mobile steam engines ...


Safehold also has fire-vine oil and a couple of other sources of bio-oils to compete with coal-slurry/powdered coal. Powdered coal may well be a solution for large steam-power installations (convertible to electricity generation in the fullness of time) but oil-fired steam power is going to be the power of choice for mobile applications for quite a while; even after the Proscriptions are lifted.

Safehold has the chance (and the stored knowledge of the TF) to completely bypass an extensive oil-based economy an move directly to TF fusion technology and/or solid state electronic motors.
.
.
.
Answers! I got lots of answers!

(Now if I could just find the right questions.)
Top

Return to Safehold