Topic Actions

Topic Search

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 67 guests

Symmyns' 30,000

This fascinating series is a combination of historical seafaring, swashbuckling adventure, and high technological science-fiction. Join us in a discussion!
Re: Symmyns' 30,000
Post by Expert snuggler   » Wed Jan 13, 2016 4:08 pm

Expert snuggler
Captain of the List

Posts: 491
Joined: Sun Jul 05, 2015 2:15 am

Even with their choice of timing and advance preparation there would be inevitable high risk.
Top
Re: Symmyns' 30,000
Post by wkernochan   » Wed Jan 13, 2016 10:37 pm

wkernochan
Lieutenant (Junior Grade)

Posts: 44
Joined: Mon May 18, 2015 1:47 pm

This brings up something I have always wondered about. Remember when the leader of the Reform movement (my memory fails me badly here) is killed? It's in a duel with a Temple Guard whom he has, I believe, trained. That Temple Guard kills him rather than wounding him and leaving him available for torture, and it is surprising that the Guard is a better swordsman. It sounds more like the Temple Guardsman is actually doing the leader a favor. He is then made the head of the Temple Guards.

Is it possible that the head of the Temple Guards is a sleeper agent for the Reform movement? Is it possible that he will back Duchairn at the critical moment, given that the leader challenged Duchairn to become a Reformer just before the leader died?
Top
Re: Symmyns' 30,000
Post by dobriennm   » Wed Jan 13, 2016 11:26 pm

dobriennm
Commander

Posts: 169
Joined: Fri Sep 03, 2010 6:44 pm

wkernochan wrote:This brings up something I have always wondered about. Remember when the leader of the Reform movement (my memory fails me badly here) is killed? It's in a duel with a Temple Guard whom he has, I believe, trained. That Temple Guard kills him rather than wounding him and leaving him available for torture, and it is surprising that the Guard is a better swordsman. It sounds more like the Temple Guardsman is actually doing the leader a favor. He is then made the head of the Temple Guards.

Is it possible that the head of the Temple Guards is a sleeper agent for the Reform movement? Is it possible that he will back Duchairn at the critical moment, given that the leader challenged Duchairn to become a Reformer just before the leader died?


There's been a lot of speculation that Maj. Phandry is a double agent (and he is not the head of the Temple Guard, just of Duchairn's bodyguards)
Top
Re: Symmyns' 30,000
Post by DDHvi   » Thu Jan 14, 2016 12:01 am

DDHvi
Captain (Junior Grade)

Posts: 365
Joined: Mon Dec 15, 2014 8:16 pm

Loren Pechtel wrote:
NHBL wrote:How far away could a crack shot, with the best gun and scope that is Safehold made (or made by Merlin in such a way that it can't be proven by the church to be other than locally built, anyway) reliably kill a selected target? (Not a PICA, just a really, really good sniper)

Long range assination may become important. Of course, the church knows that people can be shot from rediculous ranges now, anyway,


I think it's going to come down to the powder rather than the gun. Super long range sniping needs very reliable propellant.

Also, the bigger the bullet and the more powder the longer range you can shoot--ordinary sniper rifles are limited in this regard by recoil. Put too much oomph into the bullet and you break the shooter's shoulder.

snip



I once read that in the US civil war, a sniper with a heavy rifle (I think a Sharps), extra powder, and much preparation managed to kill a general at close to two miles range. In something like this, there is always an element of chance: he fired when the tent door was opened - by an aide - but the general was right behind the aide.
Douglas Hvistendahl
Retired technical nerd
ddhviste@drtel.net

Dumb mistakes are very irritating.
Smart mistakes go on forever
Unless you test your assumptions!
Top
Re: Symmyns' 30,000
Post by lyonheart   » Thu Jan 14, 2016 12:10 am

lyonheart
Fleet Admiral

Posts: 4853
Joined: Tue Sep 08, 2009 11:27 pm

Hi Wkernochan,

Welcome to the forums, please enjoy your favorite simulated beverage on the simulated forums. ;)

I'm afraid you've confused Hauwerd with Samyl Wylsynn as the leader of the Circle, and while then Captain Phandys killed Hauwerd, he was promoted to Major and heads Duchairn's bodyguard, not the whole Temple Guard.

So your premise has a major fault I'm afraid.

Other than that... ;)

L


wkernochan wrote:This brings up something I have always wondered about. Remember when the leader of the Reform movement (my memory fails me badly here) is killed? It's in a duel with a Temple Guard whom he has, I believe, trained. That Temple Guard kills him rather than wounding him and leaving him available for torture, and it is surprising that the Guard is a better swordsman. It sounds more like the Temple Guardsman is actually doing the leader a favor. He is then made the head of the Temple Guards.

Is it possible that the head of the Temple Guards is a sleeper agent for the Reform movement? Is it possible that he will back Duchairn at the critical moment, given that the leader challenged Duchairn to become a Reformer just before the leader died?
Any snippet or post from RFC is good if not great!
Top
Re: Symmyns' 30,000
Post by lyonheart   » Thu Jan 14, 2016 6:59 am

lyonheart
Fleet Admiral

Posts: 4853
Joined: Tue Sep 08, 2009 11:27 pm

Hi DDHvi,

Waiting for the general's tent door to open?

At two miles?

This sounds rather fanciful at best; more detail is certainly required before spreading this whopper.

In all the hundreds of books on the American Civil War I've read, I've never come across anything even close to this.

Now the experienced Union general John Sedgwick [West Point class of '37] was shot in hie left cheek May 9,1864 {Battle of Spotsylvania] at a range of 800 yards after telling the soldier in front of him who had ducked down "they couldn't hit an elephant at this range", who then stood, saluted and responded that he had dodged a cannonball that would have taken his head off, so he believed in dodging; the general replied "all right my man, go to your place" [on the ground] being hit just seconds later.

He was mourned all who knew him, including his good friend Robert E. Lee.

I know veterans who used to salute stupid officers in field exercises (who insisted on being saluted everywhere) "Sniper Check, Sir!" until they began to see the light.

L


DDHvi wrote:
Loren Pechtel wrote:*quote="NHBL"*How far away could a crack shot, with the best gun and scope that is Safehold made (or made by Merlin in such a way that it can't be proven by the church to be other than locally built, anyway) reliably kill a selected target? (Not a PICA, just a really, really good sniper)

Long range assination may become important. Of course, the church knows that people can be shot from rediculous ranges now, anyway,*quote]*

I think it's going to come down to the powder rather than the gun. Super long range sniping needs very reliable propellant.

Also, the bigger the bullet and the more powder the longer range you can shoot--ordinary sniper rifles are limited in this regard by recoil. Put too much oomph into the bullet and you break the shooter's shoulder.

snip



I once read that in the US civil war, a sniper with a heavy rifle (I think a Sharps), extra powder, and much preparation managed to kill a general at close to two miles range. In something like this, there is always an element of chance: he fired when the tent door was opened - by an aide - but the general was right behind the aide.
Any snippet or post from RFC is good if not great!
Top
Re: Symmyns' 30,000
Post by lyonheart   » Thu Jan 14, 2016 7:06 am

lyonheart
Fleet Admiral

Posts: 4853
Joined: Tue Sep 08, 2009 11:27 pm

Hi Keith_W,

Excellent point!

There are only 4-5 Ice Boats, and if they could carry 100 tons of cargo, they might carry several hundred men, or 10-12 trips each, or taking 4-5 5days to deliver the whole force, far too slow unless Duchairn had already seized control of the temple and city of Zion.

L


Keith_w wrote:
Randomiser wrote:Sniper range is very interesting and all, but I don't really see how it's very relevant to Maigwair and Duchairn displacing the inquisitors in charge of Zion. Symmyns will simply be relieved by order of the Captain General if he is thought to be unreliable and arrested if he refuses. No one will be allowed to semaphore Zion about what is happening and all the iceboats are part of the logistics chain, i.e. run by Duchairn's people. Yes, Clyntahn's guards will be specially chosen and warned, so will the rather larger number of the Temple Guard who will be taking them out. Come on people, either Maigwair and Duchairn are going to have a try at doing this properly or they will leave it severely alone. In this endeavour, certainly, 'There is no try, only do"

I'm not sure I see this happening, but many of the objections assume a half-hearted, half-baked attempt that we definitely will not see.


The ice-boats are part of the courier chain, not the logistics one. The books specifically state that once winter sets in, Zion is cut off from outside supply. I doubt that there are sufficient iceboats to transport 3000 troops, never mind 30000. In addition to which at the very least the captains are members of the temple guard.
Any snippet or post from RFC is good if not great!
Top
Re: Symmyns' 30,000
Post by lyonheart   » Thu Jan 14, 2016 7:25 am

lyonheart
Fleet Admiral

Posts: 4853
Joined: Tue Sep 08, 2009 11:27 pm

Hi Don,

I expect the Scout-Snipers to have first call on the smokeless powder for the two obvious reasons of the near 50% increase in power and velocity cited in LaMA and the reduced gun smoke giving away their positions.

How soon we'll see this in textev is another question.

The sniper rifles of the Corisande campaign were good for ~600+ yards, and the Mahndrayn improved on that, while the M96 with the black powder round Howsmyn held in his hand in LaMA was accurate out to 900 yards apparently, though I'd expect sniper scopes to be required at that range, which ought to be quite possible for Charis.

If the M96 is of near Mauser/Enfield/Springfield quality as its description implies, then further extended sniper ranges with smokeless powder are quite possible.

Knowing RFC's preference for pungent puns and historic references, I expect we'll soon see a Safehold version of Sedgwick's famous non-last words. ;)

The temple boys reaction to this, especially their officers ought to be delicious.

L


n7axw wrote:
lyonheart wrote:Hi Don,

The St Kylman breach loader is a modified late 18th century iron design, and while open hearth steel plants have been built, keeping in mind that all those built in South Harchong ~1/3-<1/2, are now not available to the Go4 [so I wonder where their production will wind up ;) ] we have yet to see steel versions being made or used yet, though that may change by spring.

A long range non-PICA sniper technique is too complicated without involving Merlin especially when simpler IED's have been demonstrated to be so effective in Zion itself.

Indeed, we should have heard some mention of the "Fist of God" using more rifles, pistols, and Kai-yungs, or stepping up their use to engage at longer and safer ranges for them.

Decapitation of the inquisition commanders of the Zion city Temple Guard ought to be part of Duchairn's plans [along with those Temple Guard leaders known to suborned by them], which Nynian will heartily support.

On the primary topic of this thread, the army in question is too far away this winter [south of Lake Pei], NTM I will be surprised if this army isn't or hasn't been neutralized by Clyntahn and Rayno long before they become a factor in Zion.

If Rhobair doesn't act this winter, the army might not be allowed north until BGV or DE lands at Port Home in early summer, when it'll be too late except to police the city after the surrender.

Clyntahn's paranoia was the primary reason for mentioning this force, long before Second Pasquale's blew up and Magwair began to to see Clyntahn's moves against him.

We've seen no sign yet he's ever considered any of the things Clyntahn thinks he might, which seems more an indication of how far gone Zhaspahr was then and of course he's getting worse.

Dohlar dropping out will drive him even further, as will loss of quick communication with Howard when Dairnyth falls to EHM.

Given his continuing failure with the 'Fist of God', I wouldn't be surprised if the guards outside Clyntahn's apartment have been very carefully chosen by Rayno in case of a 'personal' emergency. ;)

The jury is still out on whether Rhobair's coup will work or even if he'll survive, though I suspect he will, to lead the post war CoGA, though probably not for long before the very many arch conservatives attack him for his heresy for even meeting with the heretics etc.

Interesting times indeed.

L



Hi Lyonheart,

Your analysis is interesting.

But what was stimulating my interest at the moment was the range of sniper rifes. I think those muzzle loaders spoecially designed for snipers in Corisande were about a thousand yards or so... I wonder what your impression of a M96 would be... Getting apples to apples here, think of an M96 specially designed as a sniper rife...

Don

-
Any snippet or post from RFC is good if not great!
Top
Re: Symmyns' 30,000
Post by lyonheart   » Thu Jan 14, 2016 7:40 am

lyonheart
Fleet Admiral

Posts: 4853
Joined: Tue Sep 08, 2009 11:27 pm

Hi Jeff Engel,

Quite right.

Given how the circle was betrayed by a member who lost his soul and courage after years in it, and the fact that Duchairn hasn't had 20 years to watch all his lieutenants who are critical to his coup, it could easily fall short again; as most plots do in RFC's universes, kinda like real life.

Now, given the fact that Clyntahn hasn't had a hint of what Duchairn's been up to for the past couple of years is a good sign, especially given how closely he's watched; but a few more clues [other than his thoughts] would be appreciated. ;)

Given the revelations of HFQ, we may see some kind of contact between Rhobair and Nynian in the next book, ie Nynian's FoG may have been mentioned in Hauwerd's note; so suggestions for the next title are now open. :D

L


JeffEngel wrote:
Randomiser wrote:Sniper range is very interesting and all, but I don't really see how it's very relevant to Maigwair and Duchairn displacing the inquisitors in charge of Zion. Symmyns will simply be relieved by order of the Captain General if he is thought to be unreliable and arrested if he refuses. No one will be allowed to semaphore Zion about what is happening and all the iceboats are part of the logistics chain, i.e. run by Duchairn's people. Yes, Clyntahn's guards will be specially chosen and warned, so will the rather larger number of the Temple Guard who will be taking them out. Come on people, either Maigwair and Duchairn are going to have a try at doing this properly or they will leave it severely alone. In this endeavour, certainly, 'There is no try, only do"

I'm not sure I see this happening, but many of the objections assume a half-hearted, half-baked attempt that we definitely will not see.

The possibilities aren't exhausted by the fully prepared, carefully planned attempt with every chance of success and the half-hearted, half-baked attempt. A prominent third possibility may be something in between: a hurried implementation of a careful plan in progress that needed more time for completion; a job that's as careful as possible in the context of not having a generous amount of time to put it together; or having to make a plan that's been substantially but not completely disrupted by circumstances (e.g., a key unit transferred out of area without the plan being known or clearly suspected) work sooner than it would have taken to put it back together completely.

These aren't conspirators with the luxury of perfecting plans so much that they're near certain to succeed or not worth the bother to try. At a time they cannot do too much to put off or even predict, they may be arrested, tortured, and killed, and any number of loyal personnel and innocent bystanders killed too. So setting it off under less than ideal circumstances (in any number of ways) is almost inevitable.
Any snippet or post from RFC is good if not great!
Top
Re: Symmyns' 30,000
Post by n7axw   » Thu Jan 14, 2016 9:29 am

n7axw
Fleet Admiral

Posts: 5997
Joined: Wed Jan 22, 2014 8:54 pm
Location: Viborg, SD

lyonheart wrote:Hi Don,

I expect the Scout-Snipers to have first call on the smokeless powder for the two obvious reasons of the near 50% increase in power and velocity cited in LaMA and the reduced gun smoke giving away their positions.

How soon we'll see this in textev is another question.

The sniper rifles of the Corisande campaign were good for ~600+ yards, and the Mahndrayn improved on that, while the M96 with the black powder round Howsmyn held in his hand in LaMA was accurate out to 900 yards apparently, though I'd expect sniper scopes to be required at that range, which ought to be quite possible for Charis.

If the M96 is of near Mauser/Enfield/Springfield quality as its description implies, then further extended sniper ranges with smokeless powder are quite possible.

Knowing RFC's preference for pungent puns and historic references, I expect we'll soon see a Safehold version of Sedgwick's famous non-last words. ;)

The temple boys reaction to this, especially their officers ought to be delicious.


Hi Lyonheart,

Those muzzle loaders in Corisande were actually capable of the thousand yards according to the textev. Remember that scene on the aftermath of Haryl's crossing where Charisian snipers were climbing up the mountainside to get a shot at the defenders. Gahrvai almost gets shot twice while on his excursion to the front lines. The thousand yard figure is included there, iirc, as a part of Gahrvai's ruminations.

In actuality, it seems a bit long. I've never tried it, but at a thousand yards, a human being would be pretty tiny, especially without a scope.

Don

-

[/quote]
When any group seeks political power in God's name, both religion and politics are instantly corrupted.
Top

Return to Safehold