Topic Actions

Topic Search

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Google [Bot] and 77 guests

Spoiler Alert!!! New book possibilities/probabilities

Join us in talking discussing all things Honor, including (but not limited to) tactics, favorite characters, and book discussions.
Re: Spoiler Alert!!! New book possibilities/probabilities
Post by Brigade XO   » Mon Oct 26, 2015 12:23 pm

Brigade XO
Fleet Admiral

Posts: 3190
Joined: Sat Nov 14, 2009 12:31 pm
Location: KY

The Alignment certainly doesn't particularly worry about "collateral damage" or even that they will kill perhaps too many of the current "best" of the normal humans. They are intent on changing the population to their own designs (plural intentional) and for the most part Normals may be useful in raising the products of the Uplift Program in the same way that genetic slaves have been used to raise new decanters of the artificial wombs.

That Beowulf is made aware of the victory over and suplanting of the Beowulf Code is a fairly short term thing even in a universe that has prolong. Yes, the Alignment wants to grind that victory into the face of Beowulf but then it just has to move on with the prospect of only having that victory as a minor historical footnote. After all, the same people who will be most hurt or shocked by that win for the Alignment will soon be dead- they will have mostly become irreltevent to the Alignment and could only be seen as a continuing impediment to implimentaion of The Plan. So they get to die off if not soon killed. Not even as breeding stock since it is also possible that the Alignment will just take genetic samples for use in experimental breeding IF the subjects show attributes the Alignment finds interesting.

Remember, using artificial wombs eliminates the need for either parent to be involved in the production of the new subject and the Alignment Breeding Program people will be messing with the DNA of the subjects in any case.

The Alignment doesn't have to blast away or send plague or a number of other things to change the population of a planet. They are still going to need "workers" even if those "people" (they are probably going to find a new word for the "worker" classes) and tweeked Normals will do just fine. Or you just asign the survivors of the rise of the RF to things that need being done within existing skill sets of the survivors.

They will be changing history, one page at a time over centuries so they aren't going to bother destroying whole planitary populations since those people can be still useful but kept out of any actual power or ability to damage The Plan.
Top
Re: Spoiler Alert!!! New book possibilities/probabilities
Post by kzt   » Mon Oct 26, 2015 1:03 pm

kzt
Fleet Admiral

Posts: 11360
Joined: Sun Jan 10, 2010 8:18 pm
Location: Albuquerque, NM

There was an internal conversation by the guy running the MA which included a comment about how little they care about the edict....
Top
Re: Spoiler Alert!!! New book possibilities/probabilities
Post by Roguevictory   » Mon Oct 26, 2015 1:40 pm

Roguevictory
Captain of the List

Posts: 421
Joined: Tue May 13, 2014 8:15 pm
Location: Guthrie, Oklahoma, USA

Weird Harold wrote:
SYED wrote:The thing is if they start striking planets, it risks the collapse of the league being filled by similar acts against each other.. While they want the league to fall, they want the remains to be intact, not destroyed due to mass destruction.


I get the impression the MAlign doesn't care a great deal about mass destruction or how numerous the survivors are. What they care about is that they control whatever is left.

It would suit their purposes just as well if they could replicate Bewulf's rescue of Mother Earth (and any other successor-states) from the ravages of germ and genetic warfare. That might actually be preferable and wouldn't necessarily have to involve an Eridani Edict violation.


Wide-scale germ and genetic warfare is pretty much the absolute last thing they want happening. It was the germ and genetic warfare of Earth's Final War which originally led to the restrictions they wish to overturn after all.
Top
Re: Spoiler Alert!!! New book possibilities/probabilities
Post by shadowhawk   » Mon Oct 26, 2015 2:07 pm

shadowhawk
Midshipman

Posts: 4
Joined: Sat Oct 24, 2015 6:16 am

The textev below showed MAlign had no problems ordering edict violation when they believed they had sufficient cat's paws


from Torch of Freedom
"And your point is?" Albrecht's question could have been irritated, angry, but it was merely curious, and Benjamin shrugged.
"I know we've planned all along on reinforcing Luff, but I've never been comfortable with the notion—not entirely. It's one thing for an 'outlaw transstellar' like Manpower to be subsidizing ships which more or less just fell into its lap; it's another thing entirely for that same 'outlaw transstellar' to be supplying those pirates with newer, more powerful ships. That's my first concern. The second one is that pulling them in from their independent operations is going to be an escalation. They're going to know that we—or Manpower, at least—really have something significant in mind for them to do. Some of them aren't all that tightly wrapped, as Clinget demonstrated. They may not like the idea of Ferret, and they may try to wiggle out of having anything to do with it. At least some of them are probably going to be opposed to the notion of attacking Verdant Vista, too. Collin and I both pointed out that possibility when the idea first came up, you know. Even the People's Republic of Haven took its opposition to the slave trade seriously, and some of these people are likely to do the same thing.
"And, finally, sooner or later, exactly how they prepped for any attack on Verdant Vista is going to come out. Somebody's going to be captured somewhere else and talk, or they're just going to drop a hint in the wrong place and it's going to get back to Manty or Havenite intelligence. And when that happens, people are going to start wondering, first, just how Manpower came up with the 'reinforcements,' and, secondly, why Manpower was willing to put a bunch like Luff's People's Navy in Exile 'on retainer'—and pay them well enough to keep them there—for however long it takes."
"Agreed. Agreed to all of it." Albrecht nodded. "On the other hand, if we actually mount the operation, then probably by the time anybody on the other side starts putting two and two together, they'll have other things to worry about. Don't forget that little surprise we're putting together for Manticore out in Monica right this minute. In other words, I'd say the chances are considerably better than even that 'Manpower's' relationship with this particular batch of 'pirates' isn't going to be of any great burning significance after the fact.
"Second, this wormhole survey expedition has me worried. If we wipe out the people mounting it, and turn the system into someplace that no longer has any habitable real estate, we should also reduce interest in a 'killer' wormhole that no longer goes anywhere interesting, anyway. Not to mention getting Jeremy X and his merry band of lunatics on Torch out of Manpower's hair—and ours—as permanently as possible. And clearing the way for us to reassert sovereignty—after a decent interval, of course—over the system for ourselves.
"Third, one way or the other, within the next few months, it's going to start becoming evident that the Monican Navy ended up coming into possession of over a dozen Solarian battlecruisers, courtesy of Manpower, Technodyne, and the Jessyk Combine. That being the case, I doubt anyone's going to be all that surprised if it turns out that we had—I'm sorry, that Manpower had—a handful of additional battlecruisers lying around and handed them over to a bunch of 'pirates' it could be pretty sure would use them against Manty interests somewhere else, maybe a little closer to home.
"And, fourth, if we keep them somewhere handy, where we can keep an eye on them and they aren't going to be flailing around the spaceways making potential problems for us, we remove at least one distracting element from the equation. And if it happens we decide never to mount the operation at all, then we simply detonate those little suicide charges none of them realize 'Manpower's' put aboard their vessels. They all blow up simultaneously in a star system where nobody else is going to know anything about it, and our potential security problem goes away. For that matter, I've been increasingly inclined ever since Clinget's journals surfaced to go with Wooden Horse anyway, if we do mount the operation."
Benjamin pursed his lips thoughtfully. The chance of any of their ex-StateSec puppets ever discovering the suicide charges which had been built into each of their ships during routine maintenance overhauls ranged somewhere between ridiculously minute and zero. Personally, if he'd been aboard one of those ships, he would have been going over it with a fine-toothed comb, given all of the many sets of circumstances he could think of under which it would be convenient for "Manpower" if their mercenary pirates simply . . . went away, as his father had put it. The fact that people who'd been StateSec officers didn't seem to be even considering the possibility was only one more indication, in his opinion, of how far they'd fallen since Thomas Theisman's restoration of the Old Republic had turned them into interstellar orphans.
But, as his father had just pointed out, the fact that those charges were there was the underlying premise of Operation Wooden Horse. Once the 'StateSec renegades' had attacked Verdant Vista and carried out a flagrant violation of the Eridani Edict, every space navy's hand would be turned against them . . . including that of the small Mesan Space Navy. On the other hand, the problem might never arise if a single Mesan vessel with the activation codes for those suicide charges should just happen to arrive at their post-Verdant Vista rendezvous and transmit them while all those nasty genocidal StateSec fanatics were in range.
"Let me see if I've followed your devious thinking properly here, Father," he said after a moment. "You're thinking that we go ahead and mount Operation Ferret and use our reinforced StateSec refugees to take out Verdant Vista. They go ahead and blow out the defenders, then take out the planet itself. As soon as they've done that, we deliver their severance checks and all their ships blow up. The planet is so wrecked nobody in his right mind would ever want to live there again, so the only inherent value the system has any longer is the wormhole terminus, which has just been demonstrated to be exceedingly dangerous. At the same time, we take out a huge chunk of the Ballroom's organized support and bodyslam its morale—and that of the ASL in general—throughout the galaxy. And because nobody's going to have any interest on living on the planet, most of the galaxy probably won't be too surprised—or get too worked up—if Mesa, not Manpower, presses its claim to what's left. Most folks will probably figure that it's just Mesa trying to recoup a little of the humiliation it suffered after being thrown out in the first place."
"More or less," Albrecht agreed. "And even if it doesn't work out with Mesa regaining formal sovereignty over the star system, it should throw things into confusion long enough for nobody to have possession of it—or be mounting any more survey expeditions—before Prometheus rolls over them."
"Neat," Benjamin said, his eyes slightly unfocused as he considered permutations. "There is the little matter of the Eridani violation, though."
"We've talked about that before, Ben," Albrecht pointed out. "Either there's going to be evidence it was the StateSec renegades—who don't have a star nation anymore—or else there are going to be too few survivors, if any, to identify the attackers at all. In the first case, obviously Manpower's going to come in for the lion's share of suspicion, especially after Clinget's confirmation that it's been recruiting StateSec mercenaries. That could be . . . unpleasant, but Manpower is only a transstellar corporation, not a star nation, and nobody's going to be able to prove Manpower gave the order, anyway. That's going to create enough ambiguity and confusion for our 'friends' in the League to derail any effort to apply the edict's penalties against the star nation of Mesa. There may be demands that Manpower be punished by Mesa, but those can be obfuscated and delayed for however long we need them to be delayed. For that matter, the Alignment doesn't really care what happens to Manpower at this point, and once a full-scale Prometheus is launched, punishing 'Manpower' isn't going to be especially high on most people's agendas anyway. And then there's the fact that the only actual star nation directly associated with these people, ever, is going to have been the People's Republic of Haven. I suspect Mesa's best tactic is going to be to argue that those nasty planet-killing renegades were initially created and enabled by Haven, and that Theisman's failure in letting them escape with the Havenite warships in their possession is the real ultimate culprit in this whole tragic affair."
Father and son looked at one another for a moment, then Benjamin shrugged.
"All right, Father. I'm still not sure it's a wonderful idea, you understand, but you've managed to deal with most of my reservations. And, for that matter, you've got a pretty good track record for spotting and backing operations against 'targets of opportunity' most of the rest of us hadn't noticed. I think we can go ahead and start organizing things, even if it turns out we never launch Ferret at all. Like you say, getting all of them into the same place will make cleaning up easier if we decide to just write the entire notion off, too. Before we actually start handing them modern Solly battlecruisers, though, I'd like to get Collin and Isabel's input."
"By all means." Albrecht nodded vigorously. "I'm inclined to think this is something we are going to have to take care of substantially sooner than we'd thought we were, but I'm not prepared to start rushing in without thinking things through first. We've come too far and worked too hard for too long to start taking foolish, unnecessary chances at this late date."


Now granted things had changed since then, but the point was that they Were perfectly willing to carry out an edict violation in the past. As such one can argue that they would be willing to carry one out now, providing that is no Evidence linking to them
Top
Re: Spoiler Alert!!! New book possibilities/probabilities
Post by kzt   » Mon Oct 26, 2015 3:02 pm

kzt
Fleet Admiral

Posts: 11360
Joined: Sun Jan 10, 2010 8:18 pm
Location: Albuquerque, NM

Oops, it's David saying that the MA doesn't care.

MoH
"The people who'd planned Oyster Bay had carefully arranged their attack to avoid anything that could be construed as a direct attack on the planetary populations of Manticore or Sphinx. Given the nature of the war they were planning to fight, it wasn't because the MAN had any particular objection to killing as many Manticorans as possible. But there was that bothersome little matter of the Eridani Edict, and while it was probably going to take a while for anyone to figure out who'd carried out the attack, and how, that anonymity wasn't going to last forever. Eventually, the fact that the MAN and its allies were the only people who'd had the technical capability to do it was going to become obvious. There were plans in place to prevent the Manticorans from returning the compliment once they figured out who was to blame, but the Mesan Alignment's diplomatic strategies could be very seriously damaged if anyone figured out too soon how little the Eridani Edict truly meant to it."
Top
Re: Spoiler Alert!!! New book possibilities/probabilities
Post by cthia   » Mon Oct 26, 2015 3:13 pm

cthia
Fleet Admiral

Posts: 14951
Joined: Thu Jan 23, 2014 1:10 pm

kzt wrote:Oops, it's David saying that the MA doesn't care.

MoH
"The people who'd planned Oyster Bay had carefully arranged their attack to avoid anything that could be construed as a direct attack on the planetary populations of Manticore or Sphinx. Given the nature of the war they were planning to fight, it wasn't because the MAN had any particular objection to killing as many Manticorans as possible. But there was that bothersome little matter of the Eridani Edict, and while it was probably going to take a while for anyone to figure out who'd carried out the attack, and how, that anonymity wasn't going to last forever. Eventually, the fact that the MAN and its allies were the only people who'd had the technical capability to do it was going to become obvious. There were plans in place to prevent the Manticorans from returning the compliment once they figured out who was to blame, but the Mesan Alignment's diplomatic strategies could be very seriously damaged if anyone figured out too soon how little the Eridani Edict truly meant to it."

The inherent consistency of the ideology of master races and god complexes.

Son, your mother says I have to hang you. Personally I don't think this is a capital offense. But if I don't hang you, she's gonna hang me and frankly, I'm not the one in trouble. —cthia's father. Incident in ? Axiom of Common Sense
Top
Re: Spoiler Alert!!! New book possibilities/probabilities
Post by drothgery   » Mon Oct 26, 2015 3:37 pm

drothgery
Admiral

Posts: 2025
Joined: Mon Sep 07, 2009 5:07 pm
Location: San Diego, CA, USA

kzt wrote:Oops, it's David saying that the MA doesn't care.

MoH
...
the Mesan Alignment's diplomatic strategies could be very seriously damaged if anyone figured out too soon how little the Eridani Edict truly meant to it."
They don't care about the specific legal matter of the EE in the League constitution. They don't want planet-killing attacks happening left and right because, well, that could hit them too.
Top
Re: Spoiler Alert!!! New book possibilities/probabilities
Post by kzt   » Mon Oct 26, 2015 3:59 pm

kzt
Fleet Admiral

Posts: 11360
Joined: Sun Jan 10, 2010 8:18 pm
Location: Albuquerque, NM

No, it's that they don't want a little genocide traced back to them getting tin the way of their diplomatic efforts to conquer the galaxy. If it can't be traced to them...
Top
Re: Spoiler Alert!!! New book possibilities/probabilities
Post by shadowhawk   » Mon Oct 26, 2015 4:00 pm

shadowhawk
Midshipman

Posts: 4
Joined: Sat Oct 24, 2015 6:16 am

drothgery wrote:They don't care about the specific legal matter of the EE in the League constitution. They don't want planet-killing attacks happening left and right because, well, that could hit them too.


yet they ordered a edict violation to be carried out against torch with specified aim of rendering inhabitable. That Rozsak stoped the ex-StateSec fleet that was supposed to carry it out, does not change the fact that they ordered it.
Top
Re: Spoiler Alert!!! New book possibilities/probabilities
Post by drothgery   » Mon Oct 26, 2015 4:09 pm

drothgery
Admiral

Posts: 2025
Joined: Mon Sep 07, 2009 5:07 pm
Location: San Diego, CA, USA

kzt wrote:No, it's that they don't want a little genocide traced back to them getting tin the way of their diplomatic efforts to conquer the galaxy. If it can't be traced to them...

One incident set up to be extremely deniable is one thing. They do not want EE violations to become a regular method of waging war.
Top

Return to Honorverse