Topic Actions

Topic Search

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 29 guests

Thinking about King Zhames

This fascinating series is a combination of historical seafaring, swashbuckling adventure, and high technological science-fiction. Join us in a discussion!
Re: Thinking about King Zhames
Post by Weird Harold   » Fri May 01, 2015 5:02 pm

Weird Harold
Fleet Admiral

Posts: 4478
Joined: Thu Apr 24, 2014 10:25 pm
Location: "Lost Wages", NV

n7axw wrote:Claw has almost nothing to bring to the table apart from its location relative to the Gulf of Dohlar. ... Its harbor possibilities are limited and not all that well protected.


That's true for sailing ships, but not so much true for steamships. IIRC, the harbor itself is very good as a protected harbor, it is just difficult to sail in or out of unless conditions are just right. It was lightly defended for that reason, but the shoals that make sailing difficult will force steamships under the guns of a decent shore battery with modern Charisian artillery.
.
.
.
Answers! I got lots of answers!

(Now if I could just find the right questions.)
Top
Re: Thinking about King Zhames
Post by Isilith   » Fri May 01, 2015 7:28 pm

Isilith
Captain (Junior Grade)

Posts: 310
Joined: Thu Apr 30, 2015 11:58 am

Weird Harold wrote:
n7axw wrote:Claw has almost nothing to bring to the table apart from its location relative to the Gulf of Dohlar. ... Its harbor possibilities are limited and not all that well protected.


That's true for sailing ships, but not so much true for steamships. IIRC, the harbor itself is very good as a protected harbor, it is just difficult to sail in or out of unless conditions are just right. It was lightly defended for that reason, but the shoals that make sailing difficult will force steamships under the guns of a decent shore battery with modern Charisian artillery.


The problem with the harbor was, as you mentioned, for sailing ships. It will be no problem for a steam ship.

Also, the water issue... is not a problem. A "lack of water" was what the locals tried to peddle to the Charisians when they first showed up, to keep them from taking over and using it as a base. It said right after that, that there was plenty of water, and that the locals were over blowing that trying to keep them out. There was enough water that they were planting some veggies to supplement their food.
Top
Re: Thinking about King Zhames
Post by Louis R   » Fri May 08, 2015 11:43 am

Louis R
Rear Admiral

Posts: 1298
Joined: Thu Jan 01, 2015 9:25 pm

Anybody who thinks that wind and wave and shoal are no problem for steamships hasn't been paying much attention to the shipping news for, oh... the last 140 years or so.

And Manthyr's squadron was, what, 20 ships? 18, IIRC. 18 ships does not a major base make, especially not when most of them aren't there most of the time and therefore not drawing on the available water. Yes, the locals did exaggerate the difficulty, but that doesn't mean it isn't real.

Isilith wrote:The problem with the harbor was, as you mentioned, for sailing ships. It will be no problem for a steam ship.

Also, the water issue... is not a problem. A "lack of water" was what the locals tried to peddle to the Charisians when they first showed up, to keep them from taking over and using it as a base. It said right after that, that there was plenty of water, and that the locals were over blowing that trying to keep them out. There was enough water that they were planting some veggies to supplement their food.


Weird Harold wrote:
That's true for sailing ships, but not so much true for steamships. IIRC, the harbor itself is very good as a protected harbor, it is just difficult to sail in or out of unless conditions are just right. It was lightly defended for that reason, but the shoals that make sailing difficult will force steamships under the guns of a decent shore battery with modern Charisian artillery.



n7axw wrote:Claw has almost nothing to bring to the table apart from its location relative to the Gulf of Dohlar. ... Its harbor possibilities are limited and not all that well protected.
Top
Re: Thinking about King Zhames
Post by Louis R   » Fri May 08, 2015 11:55 am

Louis R
Rear Admiral

Posts: 1298
Joined: Thu Jan 01, 2015 9:25 pm

Dohlar isn't in the rain shadow of eastern Howard. On top of that, tropical agriculture in general tends to be rather less productive [don't let the multiple cropping fool you], although the degree to which that's true on Safehold is going to depend on how the cooler climate affects things like surface temperatures and rainfall. Your estimates for South Harchong are probably rather high.

Also, your description of Desnair is even more applicable to Harchong,

PeterZ wrote:South Harchong lies on the equator. It has approximately 50% more land area than Dohlar. More of its land area lies closer to the equator than Dohlar. Dohlar has half of the population of the entire Harchong Empire living on about 10% to 15% of the land area. All that suggests to me that SH produces much of the Empires food and is home to a significant portion of the Empires total population.

While Desnair has a larger population than SH, its economy and social matrix are less able free up extra hands for non-food producing activities. Further, the stratification of Desnairi society means fewer of its residents have a stake in Desnair as a nation. They are ruled subjects and will remain ruled subjects regardless of which set of aristocrats happen to rule. It might be argued that SH would treat their new subjects better than Desnairi nobles. Heavy garrisons might not be needed.

So, after the CoGA loses its monopoly on setting international policy, SH might well be able defeat Desnair. Especially if Siddermark distracts Desnair suitably. Siddermark was stopped at Silkiah by Zion. Absent Zion's interference, Siddermark might well take the Gulf of Jahras and the isthmus around it.

Yes this is all speculation. I believe it is sound speculation. Because even if Zion falls to the allies, North Harchong will strive against the allies. While a direct hot war might continue with the allies, the allies will not mind SH taking territory from Desnair. If Zion does not fall completely the diplomatic calculus of cold war becomes even trickier.
Top
Re: Thinking about King Zhames
Post by Louis R   » Fri May 08, 2015 12:22 pm

Louis R
Rear Admiral

Posts: 1298
Joined: Thu Jan 01, 2015 9:25 pm

It's actually extremely improbable, unless a regional organisation is typical of Harchong as a whole.

For aristocrats and bureaucrats both, rank, prestige, influence and, err, remuneration are a direct function of how far down you are from the top. The bureacrats responsible for organising the new provinces of the south would not have tolerated having to report to somebody in, say, Yu Shai when their opposite numbers in the north report directly to the Imperial Court.

From the centre, there might have been some interest in having all the south report to the South Harchong Office, but the few who stood to gain from that notion would have found themselves vastly outnumbered by those faced with the prospect of having not just one, but 2 extra layers impinging on their control of their domains in the new provinces - with one of them, even worse, not even subordinate to them in the first place. The fighting, if any, may have been interesting, but I'm pretty sure that it wound up with the administrative organisation of South Harchong identical to that of the north.


n7axw wrote:
PeterZ wrote:My only quibble with your analysis, Don, is the assumption of a lack of central authority. The Empire is ruled by bureaucrats. I would be shocked if there was not a regional headquarters for the bureaucracy. That could function effectively as a source of central authority or at least a method of exercising central authority.

It does require coopting the bureaucracy and that depends on how thoroughly Charis cuts Howard from Haven.


That could work and it would put SH a bit further ahead of the gane than I've been assuming. They could appoint an emperor to servr as a unifying symbol.

My presumption had the EOC in control of the Gulf of Dohlar after the Haarahlds and ironclads arrive and the land bridge betwwen Howard and the Havens under allied control.

Don
Top
Re: Thinking about King Zhames
Post by isaac_newton   » Fri May 08, 2015 12:31 pm

isaac_newton
Rear Admiral

Posts: 1182
Joined: Fri Oct 18, 2013 6:37 am
Location: Brighton, UK

Something about Delferak that I am not quite clear about from the map at Fifth Imperium - national and province boundary designations not being v clear - is it totally surrounded by Desnair?

Who do Myratha and Ashton belong to? They have single names like the other South Harchong provinces, unlike the Duchy this, Barony that in Desnair?
Top
Re: Thinking about King Zhames
Post by JeffEngel   » Fri May 08, 2015 1:29 pm

JeffEngel
Admiral

Posts: 2074
Joined: Mon Aug 11, 2014 6:06 pm

isaac_newton wrote:Something about Delferak that I am not quite clear about from the map at Fifth Imperium - national and province boundary designations not being v clear - is it totally surrounded by Desnair?

Who do Myratha and Ashton belong to? They have single names like the other South Harchong provinces, unlike the Duchy this, Barony that in Desnair?

They're almost certainly not Desnairian. Myratha (sometimes Maratha) is referred to in OAR as having a Prince, but that's still ambiguous between it being an independent nation and it being a province of the Harchong Empire with a ruler with that title. If that prince is a Harchong provincial ruler, it would indicate a considerable provincial autonomy though - the reference is to allowing the Dohlaran navy to use their ports on the way to Armageddon Reef. That's an unusual call for a provincial ruler not to have to kick upstairs, but maybe he kicked it to his Bishop Executor instead and considered that (reasonably) enough authority.

Ashton hasn't received even that much to help us figure out if it is an independent nation of a province of Harchong.
Top
Re: Thinking about King Zhames
Post by Isilith   » Fri May 08, 2015 1:33 pm

Isilith
Captain (Junior Grade)

Posts: 310
Joined: Thu Apr 30, 2015 11:58 am

JeffEngel wrote:
isaac_newton wrote:Something about Delferak that I am not quite clear about from the map at Fifth Imperium - national and province boundary designations not being v clear - is it totally surrounded by Desnair?

Who do Myratha and Ashton belong to? They have single names like the other South Harchong provinces, unlike the Duchy this, Barony that in Desnair?

They're almost certainly not Desnairian. Myratha (sometimes Maratha) is referred to in OAR as having a Prince, but that's still ambiguous between it being an independent nation and it being a province of the Harchong Empire with a ruler with that title. If that prince is a Harchong provincial ruler, it would indicate a considerable provincial autonomy though - the reference is to allowing the Dohlaran navy to use their ports on the way to Armageddon Reef. That's an unusual call for a provincial ruler not to have to kick upstairs, but maybe he kicked it to his Bishop Executor instead and considered that (reasonably) enough authority.

Ashton hasn't received even that much to help us figure out if it is an independent nation of a province of Harchong.



Selkar and Myratha were referenced as having princes/being princedoms. Beyond that, as you say, we have no idea.

Just from how the map is drawn, I had assumed Ashton was a province of Delfarahk. After all, Delf has 83 million people, they sort of need that land area to have a population that high.
Top
Re: Thinking about King Zhames
Post by Louis R   » Fri May 08, 2015 2:00 pm

Louis R
Rear Admiral

Posts: 1298
Joined: Thu Jan 01, 2015 9:25 pm

I was just asking myself the same question, and I'm afraid that at the moment the only answer I have is "Your guess is as good as mine"

If you look closely, you see that the lines marking them off on the map are the same as those dividing the provinces of South Harchong, and are a different colour from the lines dividing Desnair, Sodar and Harchong, but have the same form. However, while the same line is used to separate Siddarmark and Silkiah, the lines used for other national demarcations in Haven are different. More importantly, the line dividing Delfarahk from Ashton and Myratha is exactly the same as the one separating the provinces of South Harchong - which is _not_ the line used for the northern Empire.

IOW, all we can tell for for sure is that RFC doesn't have a small mind. Or, at least, that it's remarkably free of hobgoblins.
isaac_newton wrote:Something about Delferak that I am not quite clear about from the map at Fifth Imperium - national and province boundary designations not being v clear - is it totally surrounded by Desnair?

Who do Myratha and Ashton belong to? They have single names like the other South Harchong provinces, unlike the Duchy this, Barony that in Desnair?
Top
Re: Thinking about King Zhames
Post by JeffEngel   » Fri May 08, 2015 2:14 pm

JeffEngel
Admiral

Posts: 2074
Joined: Mon Aug 11, 2014 6:06 pm

Isilith wrote:Selkar and Myratha were referenced as having princes/being princedoms. Beyond that, as you say, we have no idea.

Just from how the map is drawn, I had assumed Ashton was a province of Delfarahk. After all, Delf has 83 million people, they sort of need that land area to have a population that high.

The detailed map of Delferahk (from HFAF) indicates that Ashton is north of Delferahk's border. It's a peculiarly large population for the land area for Safehold, particularly when the description of the great escape from it does not make the kingdom out to be an intensely farmed or heavily urbanized state.
Top

Return to Safehold