Hutch wrote:
Indeed, at it apparently continued in the SKM, asw Captain Bachfisch, despite being on half-pay for decades, had accumalated enough senority to get an Admirals' greeting from Honor in WoH.
"War and a sickly season" wasn't just a toast in the wardroom. It was a way of advancement during an era when seniority counted for so much. In the Navy, you either got promoted by merit (there were 30 year olds that were Midshipmen still because they couldn't pass the exam in front of a board of 3 Captains) or because the person above you died or got cashiered.
The British Army of the era was even worse. Commissions were bought and sold. Anything below General (yes, you could buy a Colonelcy and be a Regimental commander) was for sale. If your parents were rich enough you could be a Captain in charge of a company of Redcoats or even a Major in charge of a battalion as soon as you were old enough to serve. Normally, the youngsters were brought into the regiment at a far lower rank at that age, taught their job and then allowed to 'trade up' by selling their lower rank and then buying the higher one.
The American military wasn't quite that bad. The selling of commissions for officers ended rather early but seniority in promotions still ruled. There were officers that went to West Point, were commissioned as Second Lieutenants upon graduation, fought through the Indian Wars (many with some distinction) and the Spanish American War only to retire with 30+ years of service while never seeing a promotion. Some were lucky enough to reach First Lieutenant. For the enlisted it was just as bad. I've read of enlisted Marines that served 25-30 years and retires as a PFC or Lance Corporal during the same time frame.
In the Navy, a special few, like HH at the end of HoQ, got promoted out regardless of seniority and jumped those ahead of them in seniority. That could and did cause a lot of ill will. At the end of HoQ, Honor gets bumped up right to Captain of the List (skipping both Junior Captain and Commander). In SVW, she is shown pondering over whether her relationship with Mike would change now that she was not only senior to her but her new CO.