

Users browsing this forum: Google [Bot] and 90 guests
(SPOILERS) Comic review(s) | |
---|---|
![]() |
|
Rastrelly
Posts: 7
|
So, OK, guys. Let's talk serious. There are rants for the sake of rant, and there are critical remarks. I'll try to stay in critical territory for as long as possible. Also sorry for possible grammar/phrase building mistakes.
Tales of Honor #1 is out, so I ran to Comixology and bought a digital copy. Aaand what I was afraid of has completely happened. Now, there is such a sweet thing as pacing. And this story is paced horribly. Now, I'm a fan of Honorverse, and I read pretty much everything I could get, but let's suppose I'm a newcommer. And I'm instantly overflooded with long intro text, some strange torture scenes performed by some strange women, then broken by memories of the tortured one, who is a starship captain, right?.. - and she shoots someone with some strange triangular thing and brought a tiger to a starship with herself. So, what is my point? This concept does not work! At all! Pages spent on Ransom's evilness should be spent on Honor's establishment. A scene with Nimitz and Honor flying to Haephestus would be much more useful then a hundred of captions. More scenes with the crew, with ship examining, these would build the future story so much better. In it's current state the comic is a mess. I would just stop reading it from here on, if I didn't know what's coming (both on Tepes and on Basilisk Station). There are a couple of fine moments, where I see there is a potentially great moments. Crew reacting on Honor - great! Scenes with Young - a bit too simplified, but still great! Operation planning sequence - wonderful (again, I have to rant about tactical map design - it's plain useless)! But all Tepes scenes are just not needed. They are simply ruining all the pacing of the story, waking it look rushed. There are zero characters established in the first issue. Zero! Even Honor herself, being "on screen" all the time! I may be wrong, of course. But I do think that current course with comics can end up being a crash course. The story has to be less rushed, it must flow, not ram into reader. |
Top |
Re: (SPOILERS) Comic review(s) | |
---|---|
![]() |
|
BattleFalcon
Posts: 1
|
To be honest, I could live with most of that. The grav lance dual emitting thing is pretty, but way too Death Star. Also, most ship interiors are on the big side. That bridge could double as a cathedral... way too much room, not enough duty stations, and what's there doesn't seem to be arranged in anything resembling an efficient layout. But all that is minor stuff.
The real kick in the teeth is Nimitz. That beast isn't a treecat. That thing is a HUGE flat grey, fur-less, prehensile-tail-less plainsrunner with an extra pair of limbs pretty much tacked onto a terrestrial big dog frame. I'm sorry, but I am completely unable to envision that thing happily scampering along tree branches. Or managing to perch on anyone's shoulder without tipping them both over, or just dumping itself into a convenient lap for a belly rub. Or surviving a Sphinx winter without its fluffy, cream-and-grey fur. Also the face looks like Doctor von Doom's mask. Granted 'cats are an alien species and shouldn't look precisely like terrestrial cats, but this one looks like it wants to rip someone's throat out in every frame. End rant. Sincere apologies to anyone offended by this, but I just had to let off some steam. |
Top |
Re: (SPOILERS) Comic review(s) | |
---|---|
![]() |
|
smr
Posts: 1522
|
Jeez! You guys are a tough crowd!
|
Top |
Re: (SPOILERS) Comic review(s) | |
---|---|
![]() |
|
Michael Riddell
Posts: 352
|
Nah, just incredibly discerning! ![]() Mike. ![]() ---------------------
Gonnae no DAE that! Why? Just gonnae NO! --------------------- |
Top |
Re: (SPOILERS) Comic review(s) | |
---|---|
![]() |
|
smr
Posts: 1522
|
Is there a place I get the comic in digital form from the publisher or the creator's website?
|
Top |
Re: (SPOILERS) Comic review(s) | |
---|---|
![]() |
|
Telra
Posts: 300
|
http://www.eatyourcomics.com/2014/03/04/review-tales-of-honor-1/
Here, an image can be found from the comic (as far as i understand, didnt buy it, not sold over here, thos who did pls confirm) with nimitz in it, especially the face... The good news: Nimitz is not a blue lizard/biometal/alien thing anymore The bad news: Thats the only good news there is regarding Nimitz, well his looks at least. His 'face'...is giving me nightmares.... If i ever find the 'artist' that did Nimitz/concept/whatever........i will be very mean to him... |
Top |
Re: (SPOILERS) Comic review(s) | |
---|---|
![]() |
|
Starsaber
Posts: 255
|
This isn't the publisher website, but I believe it is their only digital distributor https://www.comixology.com/Tales-of-Hon ... ries/14996 |
Top |
Re: (SPOILERS) Comic review(s) | |
---|---|
![]() |
|
pokermind
Posts: 4002
|
There is a site from the comic people http://tales-of-honor.com/. Generally people don't like the new Nimitz here he is:
![]() The image comes from the above link. For more discussion of the comic to the sub forum above http://forums.davidweber.net/viewforum.php?f=19 including a message from the comic book writer. Generally people don't like the new Nimitz. Duckk moved the posts on the general Honorverse forum to the above sub-forum, and may move this one up there too so if it disappears you know where it went ![]() Poker CPO Poker Mind
![]() "Better to be hung for a hexapuma than a housecat," Com. Pang Yau-pau, ART. |
Top |
Re: (SPOILERS) Comic review(s) | |
---|---|
![]() |
|
MaxxQ
Posts: 1553
|
Probably be better to merge it with this one: viewtopic.php?f=19&t=5328 ...since both are basically review threads. =================
Honorverse Art: http://maxxqbunine.deviantart.com/ Honorverse Video: http://youtu.be/fy8e-3lrKGE http://youtu.be/uEiGEeq8SiI http://youtu.be/i99Ufp_wAnQ http://youtu.be/byq68MjOlJU |
Top |
Re: (SPOILERS) Comic review(s) | |
---|---|
![]() |
|
Uroboros
Posts: 275
|
I still haven't seen a Nimitz that really captures what he's supposed to look like. It's not bad, though. At least this one looks furry and sort-of cute in an alien sort of way.
|
Top |