Topic Actions

Topic Search

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 75 guests

Lacöon I

Join us in talking discussing all things Honor, including (but not limited to) tactics, favorite characters, and book discussions.
Re: Lacöon I
Post by Theemile   » Thu Oct 09, 2014 12:56 pm

Theemile
Fleet Admiral

Posts: 5243
Joined: Sat Feb 27, 2010 5:50 pm
Location: All over the Place - Now Serving Dublin, OH

Zakharra wrote:....The SL is HUGE. You keep ignoring that for all intents and purposes, the SL is human space. Something like 90% of all human settled worlds are in the SL (I believe that was stated in one of the first books). Manticore, Haven, the Andermani empire? Those are outlier systems.... <snip>


The SL has 1784 member systems as of ToF and an unknown # of Protectorates (Probably ~500). Haven (the 2nd largest polity) at it's highest had ~300 planets under it's umbrella, or ~16% of the number of member systems of the SL. Also in 1905, The RMN had 4 planets, and 30 or more members in it's alliance, The Andermani had just shy of 30 systems, Silensia had 67 systems, The Talbot Quadrant had 17 systems. Just this far from incomplete snapshot of systems outside the SL ammounts to ~450 worlds.

The SL probably has ~40-50% of the colonized systems in the universe under it's umbrella (counting the protectorates). The important point is most of those 1783 systems are highly industrialized with large, educated planetary populations, so the vast majority of the population, the vast majority of the educated population, and the vast majority of the industrial centers all lie in the SL, not the Verge
******
RFC said "refitting a Beowulfan SD to Manticoran standards would be just as difficult as refitting a standard SLN SD to those standards. In other words, it would be cheaper and faster to build new ships."
Top
Re: Lacöon I
Post by kzt   » Thu Oct 09, 2014 2:41 pm

kzt
Fleet Admiral

Posts: 11360
Joined: Sun Jan 10, 2010 8:18 pm
Location: Albuquerque, NM

It's like claiming that because Indonesia and the Philippines have more islands than Japan that they have bigger economy then Japan. A does not equal B.
Top
Re: Lacöon I
Post by Joat42   » Thu Oct 09, 2014 3:16 pm

Joat42
Admiral

Posts: 2162
Joined: Tue Apr 16, 2013 7:01 am
Location: Sweden

Zakharra wrote:
kzt wrote:The SL IS the financial market. how many highly industrialized systems does manticore control? How many does the SL?

SWM wrote:We aren't talking about industry. We are talking about financial markets. That infodump tells us that after the Final War, the interstellar financial market dispersed into regional centers all over explored space, and the Solarian League is no longer the dominant force in the financial market.


No. It's the Sol system that was no longer the dominate force in the financial market. Most of the regional centers of the financial market that came into being afterwards will be in SL space. The SL is HUGE. You keep ignoring that for all intents and purposes, the SL is human space. Something like 90% of all human settled worlds are in the SL (I believe that was stated in one of the first books). Manticore, Haven, the Andermani empire? Those are outlier systems. Manticore's only strength came because its wormhole junction allowed it to reach a lot of League space. Manticore's position as a regional center is unusual in that it was the only one -not- a part of the SL. That's one of the reasons the SL was somewhat bitter about the SKM. Because they didn't control it. It's that economic influence that allowed the SKM to get the SL to be officially neutral in the war between the SKM and Haven.

What SWM is essentially saying is that a large percentage of the access to those regional centers go through Manticoran wormholes/junctions because of their location, ie. it's faster to go through a Manticoran wormhole to trade financial information in the League.

Zakharra wrote:If the League wants to survive, they have to cut Manticore off from their markets. That's basic logic and a fact of survival. If the League wants to have even a chance at surviving, severing those ties is paramount so it gives the League's remaining financial markets (which is still most of human space) a chance to recover.

Yes, the League will freeze all Manticoran accounts within the Solarian League. But most of the regional financial centers are outside of the Solarian League. What I have been saying is that those independent financial markets will be forced to listen to Manticore more than to the Solarian League, because the financial market is critically dependent on the wormhole network. Manticore could force the independent markets to cut off the Solarian League, which is what you have been saying the League is afraid of. What I'm saying is that if the League tried to force the independent markets to cut of Manticore by threatening to cut those markets off from the League, I think the markets would call the League's bluff. If the League carried through with the threat, they would be doing exactly what they are afraid Manticore might do.

If the League is afraid that Manticore might cut it off from the independent regional markets, why would the League cut itself off from the independent regional markets?


If those independent systems want to do business in the SL, they will have to toe the line. And again I remind you that the majority (all but one I would say) of the regional markets that grew up after the Sol system lost its preeminent place were still located in the Solarian League. The League is -huge- and until the rise of Manticore and Haven, there were no other stellar nations that even came close to matching its power and economic might. The League has been, for all intents and purposes, the center of the human settled galaxy for nearly a thousand years. It set policy and its unlikely that the other regional markets you're envisioning ever existed outside of the League. Manticore by itself is not enough to financially destroy the League's economy or financial banking sector. It's not that large.

I thought we had textev that basically said that Manticore was the major de-facto financial clearinghouse for the League's different financial institutions. However that may be, I believe that the League has more to lose by employing a strict rule of "do no business with Manticore or any of it's associates which may be neutral parties". Also, you are forgetting that this is a League, some members will probably see the writing on the wall and just ignore or at least on the surface obey decrees from the mandarins because of economic realities as to avoid that their economies turn into low-grade manure.

---
Jack of all trades and destructive tinkerer.


Anyone who have simple solutions for complex problems is a fool.
Top
Re: Lacöon I
Post by kzt   » Thu Oct 09, 2014 5:42 pm

kzt
Fleet Admiral

Posts: 11360
Joined: Sun Jan 10, 2010 8:18 pm
Location: Albuquerque, NM

While the SL charter limits what the SL can legitimately do, financial transactions between systems and between star nations appears to be totally within the scope of what it should do. So I expect it does.
Top
Re: Lacöon I
Post by Zakharra   » Thu Oct 09, 2014 6:15 pm

Zakharra
Captain of the List

Posts: 619
Joined: Fri Jun 27, 2014 3:50 pm

Joat42 wrote:
Zakharra wrote:
No. It's the Sol system that was no longer the dominate force in the financial market. Most of the regional centers of the financial market that came into being afterwards will be in SL space. The SL is HUGE. You keep ignoring that for all intents and purposes, the SL is human space. Something like 90% of all human settled worlds are in the SL (I believe that was stated in one of the first books). Manticore, Haven, the Andermani empire? Those are outlier systems. Manticore's only strength came because its wormhole junction allowed it to reach a lot of League space. Manticore's position as a regional center is unusual in that it was the only one -not- a part of the SL. That's one of the reasons the SL was somewhat bitter about the SKM. Because they didn't control it. It's that economic influence that allowed the SKM to get the SL to be officially neutral in the war between the SKM and Haven.

What SWM is essentially saying is that a large percentage of the access to those regional centers go through Manticoran wormholes/junctions because of their location, ie. it's faster to go through a Manticoran wormhole to trade financial information in the League.


Not quite. Manticore's position with its wormhole junction is what allowed it to become a regional center. It's a bloody large one because of its reach, but it is in no way larger than the rest of the regional financial systems added together. Which is the rest of the SL.

Joat42 wrote:
Zakharra wrote:If the League wants to survive, they have to cut Manticore off from their markets. That's basic logic and a fact of survival. If the League wants to have even a chance at surviving, severing those ties is paramount so it gives the League's remaining financial markets (which is still most of human space) a chance to recover.

[i]Yes, the League will freeze all Manticoran accounts within the Solarian League. But most of the regional financial centers are outside of the Solarian League. What I have been saying is that those independent financial markets will be forced to listen to Manticore more than to the Solarian League, because the financial market is critically dependent on the wormhole network. Manticore could force the independent markets to cut off the Solarian League, which is what you have been saying the League is afraid of. What I'm saying is that if the League tried to force the independent markets to cut of Manticore by threatening to cut those markets off from the League, I think the markets would call the League's bluff. If the League carried through with the threat, they would be doing exactly what they are afraid Manticore might do.

If the League is afraid that Manticore might cut it off from the independent regional markets, why would the League cut itself off from the independent regional markets?[/]

If those independent systems want to do business in the SL, they will have to toe the line. And again I remind you that the majority (all but one I would say) of the regional markets that grew up after the Sol system lost its preeminent place were still located in the Solarian League. The League is -huge- and until the rise of Manticore and Haven, there were no other stellar nations that even came close to matching its power and economic might. The League has been, for all intents and purposes, the center of the human settled galaxy for nearly a thousand years. It set policy and its unlikely that the other regional markets you're envisioning ever existed outside of the League. Manticore by itself is not enough to financially destroy the League's economy or financial banking sector. It's not that large.

I thought we had textev that basically said that Manticore was the major de-facto financial clearinghouse for the League's different financial institutions. However that may be, I believe that the League has more to lose by employing a strict rule of "do no business with Manticore or any of it's associates which may be neutral parties". Also, you are forgetting that this is a League, some members will probably see the writing on the wall and just ignore or at least on the surface obey decrees from the mandarins because of economic realities as to avoid that their economies turn into low-grade manure.


Not quite. The texttev says the Manticore regional area is the first among equals, as in it is likely larger than any singular financial regional area. The Sol system used to hold that status as the premier and most powerful financial center. But after its fall in the Final War, that dispersed; and the League grew.. and grew.. and grew. Add all of the rest of the financial areas together and Manticore's financial area isn't that impressive anymore.
That's not to say that the SEM financial area isn't significantly powerful, but it in no way controlled the SL to the extent that SWM is implying. If it did then Manticore has already won. If it is as powerful as SWM is saying it is, the SEM owns the SL economy and can dictate terms now. But that isn't the case, he and you seem to think that the SL would be cutting its own throat if they cut off the SEM's financial district from their own. For whatever reason you think that it's so powerful and strong that the SL would be killing itself.

But.. you're ignoring the rest of the regional centers that are spread throughout the SL which is -huge-. I have seen no texttev stating or even implying that the rest of the financial districts/areas are outside of the SL. Everything I've seen says that they are since aside from the SKM/SEM and Haven, there hasn't been any stellar nations powerful enough top have created their own financial. Logic and reason and standard practice alone dictate that any financial ties have been cut, despite how much that would hurt the SL economy. You claim that the SL has more to lose if they curt the SEM off, that's incorrect. They have more to lose if they let the SEM have continued access to the SL's financial markets. In a war, especially a war like this, you do not let the enemy have access to your banking sector. You want to isolate them and put a choke hold on their finances. This means cutting off any and all flows of revenue they can. Allowing the SEM to retain its connection to the SL financial sector would be handing them a knife and bending your neck then asking them to cut your throat. The SEM would have enough access to seriously screw over the SL economy even further. No government, no matter how arrogant it is would allow that.

Many worlds economies are going to turn to manure anyways because of the massive slowdown in trade, but many systems will continue to follow the dictates of the Ministries unless they think they have a way out, or they might follow the dictates because they have no choice (ie the SL being their financial managers), and there's the distinct possibility that a lot of systems will follow them because they believe what's being said about the SEM. There has to be more than a few systems that believe in the idea that is the Solarian League.

Also remember this, despite the fact of the League's situation, everyone involved, the SL leadership, the SEM, Haven, the MAlign and everyone else knows there is a relatively decent chance that the League [u]can
survive this and come back stronger and a lot more aware. The SEM/GA and Malign both want the League to crumble because it is a danger to -them- if it survives. They know that if it survives, none of them have a chance at surviving the onslaught the League would throw at them. Even now the League's economy and economic/industrial power very much overreaches that of the entire GA. The only thing that gives the SEM/GA its edge is their military technology and they know it's a fleeting edge if the SL can build its own fleets to match their tech. That's the reason for the plans, to take down the SL before it can come back.

And the SL leadership knows this. So letting the SEM continue to have access to their financial data is beyond stupid. Unless RFC says otherwise, the financial ties have to have been cut because that's what a functioning government does.
Top
Re: Lacöon I
Post by Castenea   » Thu Oct 09, 2014 7:16 pm

Castenea
Captain of the List

Posts: 671
Joined: Mon Apr 09, 2012 5:21 pm
Location: MD

Zakharra wrote:
Not quite. The texttev says the Manticore regional area is the first among equals, as in it is likely larger than any singular financial regional area. The Sol system used to hold that status as the premier and most powerful financial center. But after its fall in the Final War, that dispersed; and the League grew.. and grew.. and grew. Add all of the rest of the financial areas together and Manticore's financial area isn't that impressive anymore.
But.. you're ignoring the rest of the regional centers that are spread throughout the SL which is -huge-. I have seen no texttev stating or even implying that the rest of the financial districts/areas are outside of the SL. Everything I've seen says that they are since aside from the SKM/SEM and Haven, there hasn't been any stellar nations powerful enough top have created their own financial. Logic and reason and standard practice alone dictate that any financial ties have been cut, despite how much that would hurt the SL economy. You claim that the SL has more to lose if they curt the SEM off, that's incorrect. They have more to lose if they let the SEM have continued access to the SL's financial markets. In a war, especially a war like this, you [u]do not let the enemy have access to your banking sector. You want to isolate them and put a choke hold on their finances. This means cutting off any and all flows of revenue they can. Allowing the SEM to retain its connection to the SL financial sector would be handing them a knife and bending your neck then asking them to cut your throat. The SEM would have enough access to seriously screw over the SL economy even further. No government, no matter how arrogant it is would allow that.

Two points and an example. Due to combined actions the SEM and the SL are mostly separate as of lacoon2. Any financial interations take place between third and fourth parties. The financial centers are where you go to raise financing for a project larger than can be financed though you own funds. Prior to annexation the regional center for the Talbott quadrant was likely Rembrant, with anything larger going through someplace in the SL (Sonderman?), now things are going through change there with big project being financed through Manticore.

The US has more than one financial center today, despite New York City's predominance. Major financial deals can also be worked in Chicago and San Francisco.
Top
Re: Lacöon I
Post by SYED   » Thu Oct 09, 2014 7:29 pm

SYED
Rear Admiral

Posts: 1345
Joined: Sun Apr 03, 2011 11:03 pm

With their access to the wormholes removes, do they even have the logistics to full scale interstellar trade any more? Especially with the limited shipping available

They might want to restrict manticor trading, but they would be busy with so much else.
Top
Re: Lacöon I
Post by Zakharra   » Thu Oct 09, 2014 9:06 pm

Zakharra
Captain of the List

Posts: 619
Joined: Fri Jun 27, 2014 3:50 pm

SYED wrote:With their access to the wormholes removes, do they even have the logistics to full scale interstellar trade any more? Especially with the limited shipping available

They might want to restrict manticor trading, but they would be busy with so much else.



That's what the SLN is planning to do with commerce raiding in Talbot Quadrant and the SEM part of the Silesia Confederacy (what is it called now?).


Castenea, thank you for the example. It's clear and concise, and shows what I've been trying to explain. I also think that both the SEM and SL are putting pressure, more from the SL, on the third and forth parties to not do business with the other side. I am not sure the financial sectors and communication routes are as porous as some people are claiming. That's my main issue, both sides would be doing as much as possible to sever the other side's revenue stream as possible.
Top
Re: Lacöon I
Post by lyonheart   » Fri Oct 10, 2014 8:46 am

lyonheart
Fleet Admiral

Posts: 4853
Joined: Tue Sep 08, 2009 11:27 pm

Hi All,

Thanks to everyone for all the great posts; its been fascinating, and informative as to what models people are visualizing.

Zakharra, I believe the early textev says the league has around 2/3 of humanity {I don't recall any that mentioned 90%], and past attempts to nail that down by yours truly back at the bar about 8 years ago got the then MWW to cut our joint total estimates down to the low double digit trillions for the SL, humanity's total evidently less than 20 trillion, but there are obviously thousands if not tens of thousands of systems, some at least a thousand or more LY's beyond the SL, given over 600 years of FTL colonization, effectively starting with dozens of systems not just one for many many times what the 'slow boat colonization era' generated.

The early textev says the MMM dominated the trade beyond the SL, giving some indication of its sheer size back then, before more recent textev declared how it now dominated the SL, despite Beowulf having a huge MM recently as well.

I believe that Beowulf has a large financial sector, that while outshone by Sol's is still quite considerable for those who just can't bear to deal with Manticore, which evidently many sollies still have issues with for some reason, but Beowulf is quite willing to take their money.

TheEmile is correct that as of CoS [1919], WEB stated SL membership was only 1784 systems, with several dozen [probably of the 'old league'] having populations 30+ billion; I tend to think 'several hundred protectorates' is closer to 700-800 systems, certainly their density in SoF and the TQ region implies something closer to that for the SL's whole surface area.

While the number of heavily industrialized systems grossly favors the SL, time won't permit that to become a factor in the SL's survival, making it moot at the moment.

Granted the 'old league' is heavily industrialized, but the quarter of the executive council's vote opposed to condemning Beowulf indicate there's already considerable opposition to the mandarin's version of events, who are just waiting to see which way to go.

RFC has stated the SEM/GA is still trading with those parts of the SL it can reach via the wormhole network, which is far greater than the mandarins suspect; so financial instruments of some kinds are still being traded, and less indirectly than some believe.

Didn't RFC state somewhere if the mandarins were tracking the relative value of the respective bonds and currencies etc, they'd see many if not most transtellars believe Manticore will survive the SL's onslaught (being better informed than the mandarins apparently), ie they already suspect how it will turn out, and have shifted their portfolios accordingly?

Keep in mind the question of how the SL will enforce it's threats against the regional financial centers etc, without the BF threat to back them up, particularly after word of Zunker and Saltash spreads FTL, that SLN BC's can't survive against RMN cruisers and destroyers?

BTW, how is Saltash further away from Sol than NT?

Don't forget the time factors involved.

Things are snowballing faster than the mandarins realise; the avalanche is growing. 8-)

While SL news and financial db's can apparently still use the wormholes [and what they have to pay and how is another indicator of the relative currency values]; non wormhole round trips to the SL frontier and back [~300-400 LY] will take up to 7 T-weeks, which puts those not connected to the GA at quite a handicap in terms of knowing and deciding what to do.

I can't help wondering if the RMN has roughly kept track of how many recognised newsies and financial db's were operating before OB etc, and restricts traffic to those it knows?

Carterage charges have probably gone up several if not 10-12 times since Lacoon 1, so those willing to pay have driven prices beyond the ability of some to pay.

The remaining SL freighters that are delivering cargoes will take 100-120 days for round trips to the frontier; if any SL freighters are bothering to visit them when there are probably far more lucrative cargoes closer to the 'old league' with quicker turn around times.

Thus practically throwing all the 'outer shell' worlds into the SEM/GA's economic network by necessity, perhaps a third of of the SL's member systems, at least as heavily industrialized like the Maya Sector, followed by the 'inner shell' systems, another third? 8-)

All of which affects how the respective economies, bonds and currencies etc are considered by the shells and the regional financial centers there, I don't think it looks good for the SL; Sol may quickly find itself outnumbered by those FC's still dealing with the SEM/GA. :D

NTM the reaction in many places in the shells to Filaretta's demise hasn't yet reached Sol again, or that the SEM/GA version got there first, since the SEM/GA access is far quicker, so the SL propaganda is falling on far rockier ground, and all that such implies. 8-)

So far we've seen no reaction from the shells to NT, Spindle, OB, Filaretta, or Zunker and Saltash; and those last are just the ones we know about! 8-)

Given the mandarins lack of interest in the mysterious perpetrators of OB, an attitude probably not shared by systems feeling far more exposed than the 'old league', I suspect the shells' analysis of the mandarins' judgement has become even more critical; I expect the news that BF is toast where it meets the RMN/GA raises their hostile attitude toward SL practices that favor the 'old league' etc to an even greater boiling point, and increases the likelihood of their welcoming GA visitors offering far better trading terms etc than the SL ever did, considerably improving the odds of their making some accommodation with the GA.

By the time the mandarins hear of such it will be far too late all too often.

By that time I expect BF to largely be debris falling into the various local stars along with whatever defending force that didn't surrender or abandon ship fast enough.

If Beowulf is indeed attacked by the SLN, sometime soon, I think far more old league systems will decide the SL no longer serves them regardless of how their EC delegates voted, and join Beowulf, if not the GA.

I expect all of these processes to be quickly cascading, so much if not most of the SL members will have quit in a year or two, and have some relationship with the GA if not the SEM, thus effectively establishing the new financial network being tied to the SEM/GA more strongly than ever.

Interesting times, people.

L


[quote="Theemile"][quote="Zakharra"]....The SL is HUGE. You keep ignoring that for all intents and purposes, the SL is human space. Something like 90% of all human settled worlds are in the SL (I believe that was stated in one of the first books). Manticore, Haven, the Andermani empire? Those are outlier systems.... <snip> [/quote]

The SL has 1784 member systems as of ToF and an unknown # of Protectorates (Probably ~500). Haven (the 2nd largest polity) at it's highest had ~300 planets under it's umbrella, or ~16% of the number of member systems of the SL. Also in 1905, The RMN had 4 planets, and 30 or more members in it's alliance, The Andermani had just shy of 30 systems, Silensia had 67 systems, The Talbot Quadrant had 17 systems. Just this far from incomplete snapshot of systems outside the SL ammounts to ~450 worlds.

The SL probably has ~40-50% of the colonized systems in the universe under it's umbrella (counting the protectorates). The important point is most of those 1783 systems are highly industrialized with large, educated planetary populations, so the vast majority of the population, the vast majority of the educated population, and the vast majority of the industrial centers all lie in the SL, not the Verge[/quote]
Any snippet or post from RFC is good if not great!
Top
Re: Lacöon I
Post by Zakharra   » Fri Oct 10, 2014 10:17 am

Zakharra
Captain of the List

Posts: 619
Joined: Fri Jun 27, 2014 3:50 pm

Those are all very good points lyonheart. I hadn't considered a few of them, but I feel that my initial point still stands. Where it can, the SL is/has cut financial ties to the SEM/GA on as many levels as possible. Although I do wonder what are the fees being paid in? Anyone in the GA taking Solarian currency knows it's going to be worthless sooner than later.
Top

Return to Honorverse